This comparison
is just qualitative and not quantitative with no numerical facts or typical
values. This comparison is inspired by some videos on YouTube and some
data in ElectroLuxAplliances.com.
|
Natural
gas cooktop
|
Electric
cooktop
|
Induction
cooktop
|
Electric supply
|
Optional for spark
|
Essential
|
Essential
|
Heating power
|
Small
|
High
|
Very high
|
Boiling time
|
Large
|
Small
|
Very small
|
Pan material
|
Any heat conductive
material
|
Any heat conductive
material
|
Heat conductive
material which attracts to magnets
|
Cooktop
components heating
|
Heated
|
Heated
|
Only pan is heated
|
Heating area
|
Constant. Different
heating areas are provided by using different eyes.
|
Constant
|
Dependent on pan
base area
|
Putting hand on
cooktop’s surface
|
Burning hazard
|
Burning hazard
|
No burning
|
Heating power
control
|
Control gas flow
rate
|
Control electric
current
|
Control electric
current
|
|
If flame is fade
out, an external source is required to ignite the gas to continue heating
|
If electricity is
out for certain time, the heater will continue heating when electricity is
back
|
If electricity is
out for certain time, the heater will continue heating when electricity is
back
|
Mechanical
maintenance
|
Difficult and
required after small operating periods due to blocking of gas paths and
galleries
|
Not required
|
Not required
|
Plug and play
|
Requires some setup.
Difficult
|
Easy
|
Easy
|
Outdoor operation
in strong winds, sandy environments, very cold places
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Boil over effect
|
§
Kills flame
§
Requires cleaning after boil over
§
Requires re-ignition
§
Hazardous
|
Continues heating
when boil over takes place
|
Continues heating
when boil over takes place
|
Cleaning and
washing
|
Difficult
|
Easy
|
Easier
|
Flexibility to
move cooktop to another place
|
Difficult
|
Easy
|
Easy
|
Effect on
inhaling in closed rooms (places)
|
Dangerous due to
emission of carbon dioxide and monoxide
|
No effect
|
No effect
|
Hazard
propagation
|
Wide (global) due to
propagation of natural gas when flame is killed and natural gas is fed to the
cooktop
|
Local
|
Local
|
Operating cost
(in Egypt)
|
Low
|
High
|
High
|
Maximum
temperature
|
Low
|
High
|
Very high
|
Pan blackening
|
Yes, because of
carbon content of exhaust gases
|
No
|
No
|
Burning of
plastic handles
|
May be burnt due to
direct flame
|
No
|
No
|
Direct visual
inspection of heat power
|
Easy
|
Hard
|
Very hard
|
No comments:
Post a Comment